Bug with duplicate user IDs of different status
Robin H. Johnson
robbat2 at gentoo.org
Tue Feb 27 05:25:34 CET 2007
On Mon, Feb 26, 2007 at 10:56:43PM -0500, David Shaw wrote:
> On Sun, Feb 25, 2007 at 06:24:03PM -0800, Robin H. Johnson wrote:
> > Instructions to reproduce:
> > 1. create any key
> > 2. gpg --edit-key ; adduid foo at bar ; save+quit
> > 3. gpg --edit-key ; revuid foo at bar ; save+quit
> > 4. gpg -v --list-keys foo at bar (shows the revoked uid)
> > 5. gpg --edit-key ; adduid foo at bar
> > 6. display will now show both foo at bar uids
> > 7. save+quit
> > 8. gpg --edit-key (now we get this message: "gpg: key 34884E85:
> > duplicated user ID detected - merged")
> > 9. 'list' shows only the revoked version of the foo at bar uid, and we
> > cannot select the new one to perform any operations on it.
>
> There is a bug here, but this also needs a clarification. In step 9,
> it is proper that only one copy of the foo at bar uid is present and
> there is no way to select one of the foo at bar user IDs: OpenPGP does
> not have a real notion of multiple identical user IDs. GnuPG, as you
> noticed, collapses them together into one user ID that carries all of
> the signatures (self-signatures, revocation signatures, etc) that were
> on both original user IDs.
Hmm, I'm wondering what the correct course of action is then.
In my original case that I reduced to the above, I originally had an
email address (rjohnsob at sfu.ca) from the university I attended, and revuid'd it
after I graduated and the email address was recycled to another user, not
dreaming that I'd be involved again with the university again (my departure was
somewhat bitter). So for some time, that address was NOT a valid source for me,
but now it is again.
> The bug is that this new, joined, user ID appears as revoked (you had
> a 50% chance of that, as the user IDs are merged in order). If you
> exit the --edit-key menu, GnuPG will prompt you to save the modified
> key (the dupe-elimination is the modification). If you say yes and
> then do the --edit-key again, you'll see the user ID isn't really
> revoked. GnuPG should reprocess the key after the user ID collapse so
> the flags (revoked, expired, etc) are set properly. I will make this
> change.
See the attached sigdata.txt file. It does show the old signatures under the
old instance of the uid.
--
Robin Hugh Johnson
Gentoo Linux Developer
E-Mail : robbat2 at gentoo.org
GnuPG FP : 11AC BA4F 4778 E3F6 E4ED F38E B27B 944E 3488 4E85
-------------- next part --------------
pub 1024D/34884E85 2002-08-27 [expires: 2008-03-09]
uid Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2006-06-23 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 X 073E939F 2002-08-31 Gerard Escalante <g2 at magestudios.net>
sig 2 X 89A343DB 2002-09-01 Graham Poulter <pltgra001 at mail.uct.ac.za>
sig 3 X 99455482 2003-05-18 Fred Van Andel <fava at gentoo.org>
sig 3 X 3BAA3AE0 2003-05-24 Rasmus Lerdorf <rasmus at lerdorf.com>
sig 3 DDCAFEE6 2003-06-30 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig P X 9E2BD1F2 2004-04-09 CA Cert Signing Authority (Low Security Key) <lowgpg at cacert.org>
sig 2 X 57983F73 2004-02-11 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 X 22B40A2C 2004-04-20 Michael Sterrett -Mr. Bones.- <msterret at coat.com>
sig 3 X CCF0FAEE 2004-09-02 Jack Cummings (John) <jack at mudshark.org>
sig 3 34884E85 2003-08-28 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 X 5A46A31B 2004-09-02 Drew Smith (mux) <drew at riotnrrd.com>
sig 3 X 6C27DEAB 2004-09-02 Randall Donald <rdonald at debian.org>
sig 3 X 5A827A2D 2004-09-02 Luca Filipozzi <lucaf at ece.ubc.ca>
sig 3 X 57983F73 2004-09-02 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 3 X B52E594E 2004-09-02 Piotr Banasik <piotr at combustionlabs.com>
sig 3 X D87C6781 2004-09-02 Jonathan Walther <djw at xouvert.org>
sig 3 X 5230514A 2004-09-02 Shaun Jackman <sjackman at gmail.com>
sig 3 X 746C51F4 2004-09-02 Kevin Lindsay (Trakker) <klindsay at mkintraweb.com>
sig 2 X 1A2870AD 2004-09-03 David Renardson <david at chspr.ubc.ca>
sig 3 X CDC9A70D 2004-09-03 Simon Kirby <sim at netnation.com>
sig 3 X 5135AF61 2004-09-03 Scott M. Rose <rose at cs.washington.edu>
sig X B32C5B38 2004-09-03 Michael Nugent <mike at illuminatus.org>
sig 3 X EFA6B9D5 2004-09-04 Hamish Moffatt <hamish at cloud.net.au>
sig 2 FD6645AB 2004-09-04 Ryan Murray <rmurray at cyberhqz.com>
sig 3 F02EB55D 2004-09-06 Norman Hodges (key3) <nghodges at interchange.ubc.ca>
sig 2 X B24B0F19 2004-09-06 Trevor Schellhorn <trevor at skinnayt.ca>
sig 3 X 2642186A 2004-09-08 Kenneth G Walker (Barrister, Solicitor, Notary http://qblaw.ca) <kwalker at qblaw.ca>
sig 3 X 06D1D3CE 2004-09-08 kwalker <kwalker at qblaw.ca>
sig 3 9E791EEE 2004-09-08 Ken Walker <kgw at lunar.ca>
sig 3 X A6A68D7F 2004-09-07 Ross Kakuschke (Work) <granola at radical.ca>
sig 3 X 36E58581 2004-09-23 Ernst Schneider <ernst at freaknob.com>
sig 3 X DCDE7E08 2004-11-04 Karl Trygve Kalleberg <karltk at gentoo.org>
sig 2 22B40A2C 2005-03-10 Michael Sterrett -Mr. Bones.- <msterret at coat.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2004-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 2 X 67FF48C7 2004-08-31 Alexander M. Turek <me at derrabus.de>
sig 1 DDCAFEE6 2005-03-10 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig 3 57983F73 2005-03-11 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 2 DDCAFEE6 2005-03-10 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig 6D8ABE71 2005-06-26 Christoph Berg <cb at df7cb.de>
sig 3 33756619 2005-06-30 Daniel Faber <mail at daniel-faber.de>
sig 58510B5A 2005-06-26 Christoph Berg <cb at df7cb.de>
sig 2 36E75604 2005-06-24 Michal \xc4\x8ciha\xc5\x99 <michal at cihar.com>
sig 60F96E8D 2005-06-27 Michael Brade <brade at kde.org>
sig A284E3D0 2005-06-28 Stephan Springer <info at Linigo.de>
sig 3 9C67CD96 2005-06-29 Torsten Veller <torsten at veller.net>
sig 2 94C09C7F 2005-06-29 Peter Palfrader
sig 5A35FD42 2005-06-30 Christoph Ulrich Scholler (FNB) <scholler at fnb.tu-darmstadt.de>
sig 03556F0E 2005-06-27 Marc Hildebrand <zypher at gentoo.org>
sig 3 0E84D2EA 2005-06-26 Olivier L. Muller <om at omx.ch>
sig 3 26F170CA 2005-06-27 Florian Brand <fbrand at redhat.com>
sig 3 2A623F72 2005-06-26 Christoph Probst <chris at netzpunkt.org>
sig 30C0F005 2005-06-26 Tobias Scherbaum <dertobi123 at gentoo.org>
sig 3DBD3B20 2005-06-26 Johannes Boeck <mail at hboeck.de>
sig 3 523C4663 2005-06-25 Mathias Landh\xe4\x75\xdf\x65r (Private) <mathias at landhaeusser.com>
sig 667F3F30 2005-06-24 Stefan Schweizer (genstef) <genstef at gentoo.org>
sig 3 9978AF86 2005-06-26 Christoph Probst <chris at netzpunkt.org>
sig CF7D6206 2005-06-25 Ulrich Plate <plate at ngenn.net>
sig 5B713DF0 2005-07-05 Frank Lichtenheld <frank at lichtenheld.de>
sig B3B2A12C 2005-07-08 ct magazine CERTIFICATE <pgpCA at ct.heise.de>
sig 16B0BE2E 2005-08-04 Alin Nastac <mrness at gentoo.org>
sig P 65D0FD58 2006-07-30 CA Cert Signing Authority (Root CA) <gpg at cacert.org>
sig 3 34884E85 2005-03-10 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
uid [ revoked] Robin Hugh Johnson <rjohnsob at sfu.ca>
rev 34884E85 2005-08-31 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2005-03-10 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 X 073E939F 2002-08-31 Gerard Escalante <g2 at magestudios.net>
sig 2 X 89A343DB 2002-09-01 Graham Poulter <pltgra001 at mail.uct.ac.za>
sig 3 X 99455482 2003-05-18 Fred Van Andel <fava at gentoo.org>
sig 3 X 3BAA3AE0 2003-05-24 Rasmus Lerdorf <rasmus at lerdorf.com>
sig 3 DDCAFEE6 2003-06-30 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig P X 9E2BD1F2 2004-04-09 CA Cert Signing Authority (Low Security Key) <lowgpg at cacert.org>
sig 2 X 57983F73 2004-02-11 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 X CCF0FAEE 2004-09-02 Jack Cummings (John) <jack at mudshark.org>
sig 3 34884E85 2003-08-28 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 X 6C27DEAB 2004-09-02 Randall Donald <rdonald at debian.org>
sig 3 X 5A827A2D 2004-09-02 Luca Filipozzi <lucaf at ece.ubc.ca>
sig 3 X 57983F73 2004-09-02 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 3 X B52E594E 2004-09-02 Piotr Banasik <piotr at combustionlabs.com>
sig 3 X D87C6781 2004-09-02 Jonathan Walther <djw at xouvert.org>
sig 3 X 5230514A 2004-09-02 Shaun Jackman <sjackman at gmail.com>
sig 3 X 746C51F4 2004-09-02 Kevin Lindsay (Trakker) <klindsay at mkintraweb.com>
sig 2 X 1A2870AD 2004-09-03 David Renardson <david at chspr.ubc.ca>
sig 3 X CDC9A70D 2004-09-03 Simon Kirby <sim at netnation.com>
sig 3 X 5135AF61 2004-09-03 Scott M. Rose <rose at cs.washington.edu>
sig 3 X EFA6B9D5 2004-09-04 Hamish Moffatt <hamish at cloud.net.au>
sig 2 FD6645AB 2004-09-04 Ryan Murray <rmurray at cyberhqz.com>
sig 3 F02EB55D 2004-09-06 Norman Hodges (key3) <nghodges at interchange.ubc.ca>
sig 2 X B24B0F19 2004-09-06 Trevor Schellhorn <trevor at skinnayt.ca>
sig 3 X 2642186A 2004-09-08 Kenneth G Walker (Barrister, Solicitor, Notary http://qblaw.ca) <kwalker at qblaw.ca>
sig 3 X 06D1D3CE 2004-09-08 kwalker <kwalker at qblaw.ca>
sig 3 9E791EEE 2004-09-08 Ken Walker <kgw at lunar.ca>
sig 3 X A6A68D7F 2004-09-07 Ross Kakuschke (Work) <granola at radical.ca>
sig 3 X DCDE7E08 2004-11-04 Karl Trygve Kalleberg <karltk at gentoo.org>
sig 2 22B40A2C 2005-03-10 Michael Sterrett -Mr. Bones.- <msterret at coat.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2004-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 2 X 67FF48C7 2004-08-31 Alexander M. Turek <me at derrabus.de>
sig 1 DDCAFEE6 2005-03-10 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig 3 57983F73 2005-03-11 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 2 DDCAFEE6 2005-03-10 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig 3 9C67CD96 2005-06-29 Torsten Veller <torsten at veller.net>
sig 2 94C09C7F 2005-06-29 Peter Palfrader
sig 3 33756619 2005-06-30 Daniel Faber <mail at daniel-faber.de>
sig 6D8ABE71 2005-06-26 Christoph Berg <cb at df7cb.de>
sig 58510B5A 2005-06-26 Christoph Berg <cb at df7cb.de>
sig 2 36E75604 2005-06-24 Michal \xc4\x8ciha\xc5\x99 <michal at cihar.com>
sig 60F96E8D 2005-06-27 Michael Brade <brade at kde.org>
sig A284E3D0 2005-06-28 Stephan Springer <info at Linigo.de>
sig 03556F0E 2005-06-27 Marc Hildebrand <zypher at gentoo.org>
sig 3 0E84D2EA 2005-06-26 Olivier L. Muller <om at omx.ch>
sig 3 26F170CA 2005-06-27 Florian Brand <fbrand at redhat.com>
sig 3 2A623F72 2005-06-26 Christoph Probst <chris at netzpunkt.org>
sig 30C0F005 2005-06-26 Tobias Scherbaum <dertobi123 at gentoo.org>
sig 3DBD3B20 2005-06-26 Johannes Boeck <mail at hboeck.de>
sig 3 523C4663 2005-06-25 Mathias Landh\xe4\x75\xdf\x65r (Private) <mathias at landhaeusser.com>
sig 667F3F30 2005-06-24 Stefan Schweizer (genstef) <genstef at gentoo.org>
sig 3 9978AF86 2005-06-26 Christoph Probst <chris at netzpunkt.org>
sig CF7D6206 2005-06-25 Ulrich Plate <plate at ngenn.net>
sig B3B2A12C 2005-07-08 ct magazine CERTIFICATE <pgpCA at ct.heise.de>
sig 16B0BE2E 2005-08-04 Alin Nastac <mrness at gentoo.org>
uid Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at users.sourceforge.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2005-03-10 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 X 073E939F 2002-08-31 Gerard Escalante <g2 at magestudios.net>
sig 2 X 89A343DB 2002-09-01 Graham Poulter <pltgra001 at mail.uct.ac.za>
sig 3 X 99455482 2003-05-18 Fred Van Andel <fava at gentoo.org>
sig 3 X 3BAA3AE0 2003-05-24 Rasmus Lerdorf <rasmus at lerdorf.com>
sig 3 DDCAFEE6 2003-06-30 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig P X 9E2BD1F2 2004-04-09 CA Cert Signing Authority (Low Security Key) <lowgpg at cacert.org>
sig 2 X 57983F73 2004-02-11 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 X 22B40A2C 2004-04-20 Michael Sterrett -Mr. Bones.- <msterret at coat.com>
sig 3 X CCF0FAEE 2004-09-02 Jack Cummings (John) <jack at mudshark.org>
sig 3 34884E85 2003-08-28 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 X 6C27DEAB 2004-09-02 Randall Donald <rdonald at debian.org>
sig 3 X 5A827A2D 2004-09-02 Luca Filipozzi <lucaf at ece.ubc.ca>
sig 3 X 57983F73 2004-09-02 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 3 X B52E594E 2004-09-02 Piotr Banasik <piotr at combustionlabs.com>
sig 3 X D87C6781 2004-09-02 Jonathan Walther <djw at xouvert.org>
sig 3 X 5230514A 2004-09-02 Shaun Jackman <sjackman at gmail.com>
sig 3 X 746C51F4 2004-09-02 Kevin Lindsay (Trakker) <klindsay at mkintraweb.com>
sig 2 X 1A2870AD 2004-09-03 David Renardson <david at chspr.ubc.ca>
sig 3 X CDC9A70D 2004-09-03 Simon Kirby <sim at netnation.com>
sig 3 X 5135AF61 2004-09-03 Scott M. Rose <rose at cs.washington.edu>
sig 3 X EFA6B9D5 2004-09-04 Hamish Moffatt <hamish at cloud.net.au>
sig 2 FD6645AB 2004-09-04 Ryan Murray <rmurray at cyberhqz.com>
sig 3 F02EB55D 2004-09-06 Norman Hodges (key3) <nghodges at interchange.ubc.ca>
sig 2 X B24B0F19 2004-09-06 Trevor Schellhorn <trevor at skinnayt.ca>
sig 3 X 2642186A 2004-09-08 Kenneth G Walker (Barrister, Solicitor, Notary http://qblaw.ca) <kwalker at qblaw.ca>
sig 3 X 06D1D3CE 2004-09-08 kwalker <kwalker at qblaw.ca>
sig 3 9E791EEE 2004-09-08 Ken Walker <kgw at lunar.ca>
sig 3 X A6A68D7F 2004-09-07 Ross Kakuschke (Work) <granola at radical.ca>
sig 2 22B40A2C 2005-03-10 Michael Sterrett -Mr. Bones.- <msterret at coat.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2004-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 2 X 67FF48C7 2004-08-31 Alexander M. Turek <me at derrabus.de>
sig 1 DDCAFEE6 2005-03-10 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig 3 57983F73 2005-03-11 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 2 DDCAFEE6 2005-03-10 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig 2 36E75604 2005-06-24 Michal \xc4\x8ciha\xc5\x99 <michal at cihar.com>
sig 60F96E8D 2005-06-27 Michael Brade <brade at kde.org>
sig A284E3D0 2005-06-28 Stephan Springer <info at Linigo.de>
sig 3 9C67CD96 2005-06-29 Torsten Veller <torsten at veller.net>
sig 2 94C09C7F 2005-06-29 Peter Palfrader
sig 3 33756619 2005-06-30 Daniel Faber <mail at daniel-faber.de>
sig 6D8ABE71 2005-06-26 Christoph Berg <cb at df7cb.de>
sig 58510B5A 2005-06-26 Christoph Berg <cb at df7cb.de>
sig 03556F0E 2005-06-27 Marc Hildebrand <zypher at gentoo.org>
sig 3 0E84D2EA 2005-06-26 Olivier L. Muller <om at omx.ch>
sig 3 26F170CA 2005-06-27 Florian Brand <fbrand at redhat.com>
sig 3 2A623F72 2005-06-26 Christoph Probst <chris at netzpunkt.org>
sig 30C0F005 2005-06-26 Tobias Scherbaum <dertobi123 at gentoo.org>
sig 3DBD3B20 2005-06-26 Johannes Boeck <mail at hboeck.de>
sig 3 523C4663 2005-06-25 Mathias Landh\xe4\x75\xdf\x65r (Private) <mathias at landhaeusser.com>
sig 667F3F30 2005-06-24 Stefan Schweizer (genstef) <genstef at gentoo.org>
sig 3 9978AF86 2005-06-26 Christoph Probst <chris at netzpunkt.org>
sig CF7D6206 2005-06-25 Ulrich Plate <plate at ngenn.net>
sig B3B2A12C 2005-07-08 ct magazine CERTIFICATE <pgpCA at ct.heise.de>
sig 16B0BE2E 2005-08-04 Alin Nastac <mrness at gentoo.org>
sig P 65D0FD58 2006-07-30 CA Cert Signing Authority (Root CA) <gpg at cacert.org>
uid Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at gentoo.org>
sig 3 34884E85 2006-06-23 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 X 99455482 2003-05-18 Fred Van Andel <fava at gentoo.org>
sig 3 X 3BAA3AE0 2003-05-24 Rasmus Lerdorf <rasmus at lerdorf.com>
sig 3 DDCAFEE6 2003-06-30 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig P X 9E2BD1F2 2004-04-09 CA Cert Signing Authority (Low Security Key) <lowgpg at cacert.org>
sig 2 X 57983F73 2004-02-11 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2003-04-03 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2003-04-03 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 X 22B40A2C 2004-04-20 Michael Sterrett -Mr. Bones.- <msterret at coat.com>
sig 3 X CCF0FAEE 2004-09-02 Jack Cummings (John) <jack at mudshark.org>
sig 3 34884E85 2003-08-28 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 X 6C27DEAB 2004-09-02 Randall Donald <rdonald at debian.org>
sig 3 X 5A827A2D 2004-09-02 Luca Filipozzi <lucaf at ece.ubc.ca>
sig 3 X 57983F73 2004-09-02 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 3 X B52E594E 2004-09-02 Piotr Banasik <piotr at combustionlabs.com>
sig 3 X D87C6781 2004-09-02 Jonathan Walther <djw at xouvert.org>
sig 3 X 5230514A 2004-09-02 Shaun Jackman <sjackman at gmail.com>
sig 3 X 746C51F4 2004-09-02 Kevin Lindsay (Trakker) <klindsay at mkintraweb.com>
sig 2 X 1A2870AD 2004-09-03 David Renardson <david at chspr.ubc.ca>
sig 3 X CDC9A70D 2004-09-03 Simon Kirby <sim at netnation.com>
sig 3 X 5135AF61 2004-09-03 Scott M. Rose <rose at cs.washington.edu>
sig 3 X EFA6B9D5 2004-09-04 Hamish Moffatt <hamish at cloud.net.au>
sig 2 FD6645AB 2004-09-04 Ryan Murray <rmurray at cyberhqz.com>
sig 3 F02EB55D 2004-09-06 Norman Hodges (key3) <nghodges at interchange.ubc.ca>
sig 2 X B24B0F19 2004-09-06 Trevor Schellhorn <trevor at skinnayt.ca>
sig 3 X 2642186A 2004-09-08 Kenneth G Walker (Barrister, Solicitor, Notary http://qblaw.ca) <kwalker at qblaw.ca>
sig 3 X 06D1D3CE 2004-09-08 kwalker <kwalker at qblaw.ca>
sig 3 9E791EEE 2004-09-08 Ken Walker <kgw at lunar.ca>
sig 3 X A6A68D7F 2004-09-07 Ross Kakuschke (Work) <granola at radical.ca>
sig 3 X DCDE7E08 2004-11-04 Karl Trygve Kalleberg <karltk at gentoo.org>
sig 2 22B40A2C 2005-03-10 Michael Sterrett -Mr. Bones.- <msterret at coat.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2004-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 2 X 67FF48C7 2004-08-31 Alexander M. Turek <me at derrabus.de>
sig 1 DDCAFEE6 2005-03-10 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig 3 57983F73 2005-03-11 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 2 DDCAFEE6 2005-03-10 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig A284E3D0 2005-06-28 Stephan Springer <info at Linigo.de>
sig 6D8ABE71 2005-06-26 Christoph Berg <cb at df7cb.de>
sig 58510B5A 2005-06-26 Christoph Berg <cb at df7cb.de>
sig 2 36E75604 2005-06-24 Michal \xc4\x8ciha\xc5\x99 <michal at cihar.com>
sig 60F96E8D 2005-06-27 Michael Brade <brade at kde.org>
sig 3 33756619 2005-06-30 Daniel Faber <mail at daniel-faber.de>
sig 2 94C09C7F 2005-06-29 Peter Palfrader
sig 3 9C67CD96 2005-06-29 Torsten Veller <torsten at veller.net>
sig 03556F0E 2005-06-27 Marc Hildebrand <zypher at gentoo.org>
sig 3 0E84D2EA 2005-06-26 Olivier L. Muller <om at omx.ch>
sig 3 26F170CA 2005-06-27 Florian Brand <fbrand at redhat.com>
sig 3 2A623F72 2005-06-26 Christoph Probst <chris at netzpunkt.org>
sig 30C0F005 2005-06-26 Tobias Scherbaum <dertobi123 at gentoo.org>
sig 3DBD3B20 2005-06-26 Johannes Boeck <mail at hboeck.de>
sig 3 523C4663 2005-06-25 Mathias Landh\xe4\x75\xdf\x65r (Private) <mathias at landhaeusser.com>
sig 667F3F30 2005-06-24 Stefan Schweizer (genstef) <genstef at gentoo.org>
sig 3 9978AF86 2005-06-26 Christoph Probst <chris at netzpunkt.org>
sig CF7D6206 2005-06-25 Ulrich Plate <plate at ngenn.net>
sig B3B2A12C 2005-07-08 ct magazine CERTIFICATE <pgpCA at ct.heise.de>
sig 16B0BE2E 2005-08-04 Alin Nastac <mrness at gentoo.org>
sig P 65D0FD58 2006-07-30 CA Cert Signing Authority (Root CA) <gpg at cacert.org>
sig FBD72601 2006-07-29 Hisashi Todd Fujinaka <htodd at twofifty.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2005-03-10 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
uid [ revoked] Robin Hugh Johnson <rhj at sfu.ca>
rev 34884E85 2004-04-20 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 DDCAFEE6 2003-06-30 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig 2 X 57983F73 2004-02-11 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 3 X 99455482 2003-05-18 Fred Van Andel <fava at gentoo.org>
sig 3 X 3BAA3AE0 2003-05-24 Rasmus Lerdorf <rasmus at lerdorf.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2003-08-28 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2003-03-30 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2003-03-30 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
uid [ revoked] Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at sfu.ca>
rev 34884E85 2004-04-20 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 DDCAFEE6 2003-06-30 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig 2 X 89A343DB 2002-09-01 Graham Poulter <pltgra001 at mail.uct.ac.za>
sig 2 X 57983F73 2004-02-11 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 3 X 073E939F 2002-08-31 Gerard Escalante <g2 at magestudios.net>
sig 3 X 99455482 2003-05-18 Fred Van Andel <fava at gentoo.org>
sig 3 X 3BAA3AE0 2003-05-24 Rasmus Lerdorf <rasmus at lerdorf.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2003-08-28 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
uid [ revoked] Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at hotmail.com>
rev 34884E85 2004-04-20 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 2 X 89A343DB 2002-09-01 Graham Poulter <pltgra001 at mail.uct.ac.za>
sig 2 X 57983F73 2004-02-11 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 3 X 073E939F 2002-08-31 Gerard Escalante <g2 at magestudios.net>
sig 3 X 99455482 2003-05-18 Fred Van Andel <fava at gentoo.org>
sig 3 X 3BAA3AE0 2003-05-24 Rasmus Lerdorf <rasmus at lerdorf.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2003-08-28 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2002-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
uid [ revoked] Robin Hugh Johnson <robin at corasen.com>
rev 34884E85 2005-08-31 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2005-03-10 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 X CCF0FAEE 2004-09-02 Jack Cummings (John) <jack at mudshark.org>
sig 3 34884E85 2004-06-01 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 X 6C27DEAB 2004-09-02 Randall Donald <rdonald at debian.org>
sig 3 X 5A827A2D 2004-09-02 Luca Filipozzi <lucaf at ece.ubc.ca>
sig 3 X 57983F73 2004-09-02 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 3 X B52E594E 2004-09-02 Piotr Banasik <piotr at combustionlabs.com>
sig 3 X D87C6781 2004-09-02 Jonathan Walther <djw at xouvert.org>
sig 3 X 5230514A 2004-09-02 Shaun Jackman <sjackman at gmail.com>
sig 3 X 746C51F4 2004-09-02 Kevin Lindsay (Trakker) <klindsay at mkintraweb.com>
sig 2 X 1A2870AD 2004-09-03 David Renardson <david at chspr.ubc.ca>
sig 3 X CDC9A70D 2004-09-03 Simon Kirby <sim at netnation.com>
sig 3 X 5135AF61 2004-09-03 Scott M. Rose <rose at cs.washington.edu>
sig 3 X EFA6B9D5 2004-09-04 Hamish Moffatt <hamish at cloud.net.au>
sig 2 FD6645AB 2004-09-04 Ryan Murray <rmurray at cyberhqz.com>
sig 3 F02EB55D 2004-09-06 Norman Hodges (key3) <nghodges at interchange.ubc.ca>
sig 2 X B24B0F19 2004-09-06 Trevor Schellhorn <trevor at skinnayt.ca>
sig 3 X 2642186A 2004-09-08 Kenneth G Walker (Barrister, Solicitor, Notary http://qblaw.ca) <kwalker at qblaw.ca>
sig 3 X 06D1D3CE 2004-09-08 kwalker <kwalker at qblaw.ca>
sig 3 9E791EEE 2004-09-08 Ken Walker <kgw at lunar.ca>
sig 3 X A6A68D7F 2004-09-07 Ross Kakuschke (Work) <granola at radical.ca>
sig 2 22B40A2C 2005-03-10 Michael Sterrett -Mr. Bones.- <msterret at coat.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2004-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 2 X 67FF48C7 2004-08-31 Alexander M. Turek <me at derrabus.de>
sig 1 DDCAFEE6 2005-03-10 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig 3 57983F73 2005-03-11 Piotr Banasik <piotr at t-p-l.com>
sig 2 DDCAFEE6 2005-03-10 Mayo Jordanov <mayo at nfy.ca>
sig A284E3D0 2005-06-28 Stephan Springer <info at Linigo.de>
sig 3 9C67CD96 2005-06-29 Torsten Veller <torsten at veller.net>
sig 3 33756619 2005-06-30 Daniel Faber <mail at daniel-faber.de>
sig 6D8ABE71 2005-06-26 Christoph Berg <cb at df7cb.de>
sig 58510B5A 2005-06-26 Christoph Berg <cb at df7cb.de>
sig 2 36E75604 2005-06-24 Michal \xc4\x8ciha\xc5\x99 <michal at cihar.com>
sig 60F96E8D 2005-06-27 Michael Brade <brade at kde.org>
sig 2 94C09C7F 2005-06-29 Peter Palfrader
sig 03556F0E 2005-06-27 Marc Hildebrand <zypher at gentoo.org>
sig 3 0E84D2EA 2005-06-26 Olivier L. Muller <om at omx.ch>
sig 3 26F170CA 2005-06-27 Florian Brand <fbrand at redhat.com>
sig 3 2A623F72 2005-06-26 Christoph Probst <chris at netzpunkt.org>
sig 30C0F005 2005-06-26 Tobias Scherbaum <dertobi123 at gentoo.org>
sig 3DBD3B20 2005-06-26 Johannes Boeck <mail at hboeck.de>
sig 3 523C4663 2005-06-25 Mathias Landh\xe4\x75\xdf\x65r (Private) <mathias at landhaeusser.com>
sig 667F3F30 2005-06-24 Stefan Schweizer (genstef) <genstef at gentoo.org>
sig 3 9978AF86 2005-06-26 Christoph Probst <chris at netzpunkt.org>
sig CF7D6206 2005-06-25 Ulrich Plate <plate at ngenn.net>
sig B3B2A12C 2005-07-08 ct magazine CERTIFICATE <pgpCA at ct.heise.de>
sig 16B0BE2E 2005-08-04 Alin Nastac <mrness at gentoo.org>
uid [ revoked] Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at net-conex.com>
rev 34884E85 2006-05-19 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 3 34884E85 2005-08-31 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
uid Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at livejournal.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2006-06-23 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig P 65D0FD58 2006-07-30 CA Cert Signing Authority (Root CA) <gpg at cacert.org>
uid Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at alumni.sfu.ca>
sig 3 34884E85 2006-07-30 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
uid Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at isohunt.com>
sig 3 34884E85 2007-02-25 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
uid Robin Hugh Johnson <rjohnsob at sfu.ca>
sig 3 34884E85 2007-02-25 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sub 2048g/CA05A397 2002-08-27 [expires: 2008-03-09]
sig 34884E85 2005-03-10 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sub 2048g/67592A1F 2003-04-12 [expires: 2008-03-09]
sig 34884E85 2005-03-10 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sub 1024D/FB33B3A4 2002-08-27 [revoked: 2004-09-09]
rev 34884E85 2004-09-09 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 34884E85 2004-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sub 2048g/CC772FC3 2002-08-27 [revoked: 2004-09-09]
rev 34884E85 2004-09-09 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sig 34884E85 2004-08-27 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sub 1024D/3233C22C 2004-08-29 [expires: 2008-03-09]
sig 34884E85 2006-06-23 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sub 1024D/A8E87991 2006-06-23 [expires: 2008-06-22]
sig 34884E85 2006-06-23 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sub 1024D/9CA1EFD7 2006-06-23 [expires: 2008-06-22]
sig 34884E85 2006-06-23 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
sub 2048R/66D8F49B 2006-06-23 [expires: 2008-06-22]
sig 34884E85 2006-06-23 Robin Hugh Johnson <robbat2 at orbis-terrarum.net>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: application/pgp-signature
Size: 321 bytes
Desc: not available
Url : /pipermail/attachments/20070226/13429b11/attachment-0001.pgp
More information about the Gnupg-devel
mailing list