WKD lookup

[Jürgen Schäpker]

Hi,


 >This doesn't seem to be a concern of this (draft) standard. HTTP Host: 
is well
 >standardized and defined. You should solve this there, in your 
webserver/proxy.
 >This is just sensible layering of protocols. You should strive to solve 
the
 >problems in the correct layer. Sometimes a little layering violation is 
still
 >the lesser of evils, but I really don't think that applies here.

You will not increase the adoption rate for OpenPGP if the standard just 
creates unnecessary requirements for no good reason.

I see no advantage why the hash should be calculated from local-part 
only and not from the full Email-address.

 >*Especially*
 >with IDN! That only makes it worse. How many independent IDN 
implementations
 >in how many layers do you want to add?

One might be enough, on MUA and WKD server. libidn ToASCII should be 
able do it, not?


best regards,
JS