bad sig with gpg but good sig with pgp5.0i and pgp6.5.8

Tue, 5 Dec 2000 13:34:07 +0100

--------------Boundary-00=_VKH351O302IGJLA6Q69Q
Content-Type: text/plain;
  charset="iso-8859-1"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Hi,

yesterday i received the attached and pgp signed email. It has been 
signed by PGP 5.0i with the counterpart of the attached key. (I 
attached the key twice. The first one is the key Michael send me and 
the second one is Michael's public key reexported via GPG.)

The problem is that PGP 5.0i and PGP 6.5.8 both tell me that the 
signature is good. But GPG 1.0.4 says the signature is bad. I looked in 
the FAQ, the HowTos, the GPH and the mailing list archive but I still 
got no clue.

The only thing a remarked was that the output of PGP (both versions) is 
one byte (a LF) shorter than the output of GPG. But removing the last 
LF before "-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE" didn't help, although GPG then 
produced the same output as PGP.

I also tried all available hash algorithms and --force-v3-sigs without 
success.

Where is the problem?

Regards,
Ingo

- -- 
Ingo Klöcker
Lehrstuhl A für Mathematik
RWTH Aachen
52056 Aachen
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.0.4 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: For info see http://www.gnupg.org

iD8DBQE6LODAqUQWN/hplRsRAhI7AJwIjlOu4AcjkSNacz7Mc9UTCFqKuQCghKr7
Htvmp6ldCIXqIDTeWLLSrjo=
=0b/V
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--------------Boundary-00=_VKH351O302IGJLA6Q69Q
Content-Type: message/rfc822;
  charset="iso-8859-1";
  name="michael-0512-latin1.mail"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Content-Description: the signed email
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="michael-0512-latin1.mail"

>From Michael.Haeckel@stud.uni-bayreuth.de Mon Dec  4 21:54:03 2000

Received: from nets5.rz.rwth-aachen.de (nets5.rz.RWTH-Aachen.DE [137.226.144.13])
	by helena.mathA.rwth-aachen.de (SGI-8.9.3/8.9.3) with ESMTP id VAA25820
	for <ingo@matha.rwth-aachen.de>; Mon, 4 Dec 2000 21:55:27 +0100 (MET)
Received: from mout1.freenet.de (exim@mout1.freenet.de [194.97.50.132])
	by nets5.rz.rwth-aachen.de (8.10.1/8.10.1/5) with ESMTP id eB4KtQm29467
	for <ingo@matha.rwth-aachen.de>; Mon, 4 Dec 2000 21:55:27 +0100 (MET)
Received: from [194.97.50.138] (helo=mx0.freenet.de)
	by mout1.freenet.de with esmtp (Exim 3.20 #2)
	id 1432dF-0001XM-00
	for ingo@matha.rwth-aachen.de; Mon, 04 Dec 2000 21:54:41 +0100
Received: from aff94.pppool.de ([213.6.255.148] helo=michael)
	by mx0.freenet.de with smtp (Exim 3.20 #2)
	id 1432dE-0007Oi-00
	for ingo@mathA.rwth-aachen.de; Mon, 04 Dec 2000 21:54:40 +0100
Content-Type: text/plain;
  charset="iso-8859-1"
From: Michael Haeckel <Michael.Haeckel@stud.uni-bayreuth.de>
To: Ingo Kloecker <ingo@matha.rwth-aachen.de>
Subject: Re: PATCH: Bug#16362: gpg: only latin1 messages can be signed correctly
Date: Mon, 4 Dec 2000 21:54:03 +0100
X-Mailer: KMail [version 1.2]
References: <200012011727.SAA06497@helena.mathA.rwth-aachen.de> <00120410594100.02469@michael> <0012042056230B.12541@atlas>
In-Reply-To: <0012042056230B.12541@atlas>
X-Accept-Language: de, en
MIME-Version: 1.0
Message-Id: <00120421540300.05232@michael>
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit
Status: R 
X-Status: N

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----

On Monday,  4. December 2000 20:56, you wrote:

>

> Ich habe deine Mail mit der laut GPG fehlerhaften Signatur mal

> angehaengt (von KMail aus abgespeichert). Auch bei manueller

> Ueberpruefung der abgespeicherten Mail meldet GPG eine fehlerhafte

> Signatur. Die zweite von dir signierte Mail (PATCH2: Bug#16362 ...) hat

> uebrigens auch eine fehlerhafte Signatur.

Laut PGP hier immer noch korrekt.
Die Signaturen deiner Mails werden hier von PGP auch als korrekt gemeldet,
nachdem ich deinen Schlüssel in meine Liste aufgenommen habe.

Kann es sein, daß ich die selbe Adresse im From: header verwenden muß, als
ich für den Schlüssel verwendet habe? In diesem Mail mache ich das einmal.

> Weisst du zufaellig welche Schriftart du als utf-8-Font installiert

> hast? Aendert sich die Schriftart beim Wechsel von koi8-r encoding zu

> utf-8 encoding? Bei mir sieht die utf-8 Schrift genau so aus wie die

> latin1 Schrift, waehrend die koi8-r Schrift deutlich breiter ist.

Als unicode Font habe ich Fixed, die Kodierung heißt nicht utf-8, sondern
iso10646-1.
Das mit der Breite ist bei mir auch ähnlich. Seit ich nur noch unicode für
die Mails verwende natürlich nicht mehr.

Viele Grüße,
Michael Häckel

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: PGPfreeware 5.0i for non-commercial use
MessageID: GL8h9oWzVePQQFZx6lH+o7j1Lonkn4s5

iQA/AwUAOiwEbg7c1ZAtjdZKEQKE7QCgkXiIoOK+k2vSkofNawgpmRn/8aUAn2QL
kl9QzHkWk6Pve1MfGix7NP6o
=2uo3
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--------------Boundary-00=_VKH351O302IGJLA6Q69Q
Content-Type: text/plain;
  charset="iso-8859-1";
  name="michael_haeckel_public_key.asc"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Description: Michael Haeckel's public key
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="michael_haeckel_public_key.asc"
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--------------Boundary-00=_VKH351O302IGJLA6Q69Q
Content-Type: application/pgp-keys;
  name="public_key.asc"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Description: Michael Haeckel's key reexported via GPG
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="public_key.asc"

LS0tLS1CRUdJTiBQR1AgUFVCTElDIEtFWSBCTE9DSy0tLS0tClZlcnNpb246IEdudVBHIHYxLjAu
NCAoR05VL0xpbnV4KQpDb21tZW50OiBGb3IgaW5mbyBzZWUgaHR0cDovL3d3dy5nbnVwZy5vcmcK
Cm1RR2lCRGp0cWJBUkJBRGUzc2p6ajNHak9sVnFSWDJDdElLZkVlemszWkhpWEtJcFgzZnJJYlVp
UWx2d1RPTWEKVjZnVmlPdWhmanVGdHpXRXJ5Q2s4byt5c29NVzVVaW5ZOTRyZTRJNkMreEdKa2Uv
bXFEV292bG81RldHbWQxcQprNHpuQnhPcDVSK2VPTW5uWjAxMGZTUDgyb3A5ZmdGelFKRGwzTEpC
MEpLTkNFUWNpM1Rwbit2OTd3Q2cvL1pXCnNNRU1hOHN2bjdGeXhmaC9Mbi9hV1E4RUFLVGZDN0NS
dlpxL1BGdStMaTdQR0pna0M5SWZFVk00bURMTnVzQzEKZ3JSM0M3ZnVuNnZOVTB1Z0t6a0FXcnRO
Q1phY09QcXQ4bnk0RkdJaFd3R3YzY2E2azBJbHU5ZU85cDFIUDFpSQpNc24yNzRkVVhOUHdPQVl5
VG5YQkVsNGdMa2krT09jbUhjZGNORTgrbkR6c1duUUVCWFMwK2JxL3RSa3I4aXB5CmtOOXRBLzlB
eEVWbFVsZGlWaWplS2dJdEZxdU9MQlJKYVNLcTh2MGkzelV5VTFpQjFxQzA3Q3o1RXRaTG5sMTYK
ajVHdWIyTGxSVlg1YWt3RkVRakt2b3BhYmNMWWdWZXhxdjRkOFNXNTJka3J3NUdsT0g5ZHJ2aUcx
SXBvVnZPeApYS2FqeEkwaGhJbGF6eFluQkZUOFlqQlhac1dnbzhib2g3cllRQVRCd3F5ZTBzN1ZG
clEyVFdsamFHRmxiQ0JJCllXVmphMlZzSUR4TmFXTm9ZV1ZzTGtoaFpXTnJaV3hBYzNSMVpDNTFi
bWt0WW1GNWNtVjFkR2d1WkdVK2lFc0UKRUJFQ0FBc0ZBamp0cWJBRUN3TUJBZ0FLQ1JBTzNOV1FM
WTNXU3NROUFKNHZWbmZoamtVYXRPbU5OaEpCRDZGdgo5Q2lOUlFDZlhzYm0ySHU2TFVoZERhRGl6
ZGxyZWpzZTFRUzVBUTBFT08ycHZoQUVBT2QyTWY1REpEWllEdTFECm9BZGxSdzRiTWhQb3lHMklO
dVV2M05aV2N2bVZmb1U3T0RtcFZ1R3dRanJnOEFvZE5LaTlNZnN2Sm95UFM4bDEKMHA0UHhkZVIr
dk43M3FzSFg1WTZJcTRqcU5xV1RXOG4yQUd3b2NVUlFSSUNhdlBXOFBNM1VzNlZhTVVmcmR1NAps
WEFUUEY4OEJXdldJdDM5VGtWeGdCM3EyTUVCQUFJQ0JBRGdzQ056Tkt1ditYNVlldUFpM0hqMG5r
elM1WEs5CnllbVZDd0kvV2l2T1AvOUx6MUpoRVZxR3JoOFBxcDU5WjF4SU1wQ0xSNHlrejhyaUlq
Z2JsK0RZbG5XT3NTbGEKdFZteWJRWmU4Smp2Uk83bmI4clZiSVB1K2RPcFd3ZHdKb3R2ZHk1b2x6
YUlSRkdkOEpNV2w1aE5TSGVWYnZyMgpBVXRPbUlvRnZRSlJDSWcvQXdVWU9PMnB2ZzdjMVpBdGpk
WktFUUlObndDZlF2dS9xelVWQ2Vnb0FNbmpaMENCClpEUEVadklBb084dUFlVDJaY1FPQVZqc0FC
N2gvbStuN2pMbQo9WEZXMQotLS0tLUVORCBQR1AgUFVCTElDIEtFWSBCTE9DSy0tLS0tCg==

--------------Boundary-00=_VKH351O302IGJLA6Q69Q--

-- 
Archive is at http://lists.gnupg.org - Unsubscribe by sending mail
with a subject of  "unsubscribe"  to gnupg-users-request@gnupg.org