Signature verification problem

Konrad Podloucky konrad@crunchy-frog.org
Wed Jul 31 16:14:01 2002



------=_rE+2ToM)u)Slt6Q9N1.N6lerMQeL3s3Ge?hOe4ym7uCUUmuF/Ihy2ac+g'JR
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=iso-8859-1
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit

Hi guys,

I'm just in the process of evaluating some OpenPGP solutions for the
company I work for, and I stumbled onto this problem:
I used CryptoEx' Outlook plugin to cleartext-sign a mail, which I tried to
verify with gpg.
gpg gives me a BAD signature (both 1.0.6 and 1.0.7). However CryptoEx'
plugin verifies the signature as being good (OK, otherwise it would be
pretty embarrassing) and NAI's PGP (7.0.3) also says that the signature is
ok.

I've attached the relevant message and the public part of the key used to
sign the message. Unfortunately I don't have enough knowledge about the
OpenPGP standard or the implementations to give this problem a better look.
Would be great if somebody could shed some light on this issue.

Thx,
     Konrad


------=_rE+2ToM)u)Slt6Q9N1.N6lerMQeL3s3Ge?hOe4ym7uCUUmuF/Ihy2ac+g'JR
Content-Type: text/plain; name="msg.txt"
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="msg.txt"

Subject: pgp test
   From: "Konrad Podloucky" <konrad.podloucky@dox-at.com>
     To: <konrad@crunchy-frog.org>
   Date: Wed, July 31, 2002 15:49

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----

This is a signature test.

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: CryptoEx OpenPGP Engine Version 2.1
Comment: CryptoEx Client Suite - http://www.cryptoex.com

iQA/AwUBPUfqzwNb34kz7XLGEQLVwACg2qM2OdqTRdyMdZUFP3+kPToB3HMAnR/z
qQ33vUbsEeEwdT78gRxccWwW
=PB94
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----


----------------------------------------------------------------------------
---
This mail was sent using CryptoEx Outlook Private Edition (Freeware).
Authorized for non-commercial, non-governmental usage only.
(c) Glueck & Kanja Technology AG, (c) SECUDE GmbH. All rights reserved.
For commercial licensing information visit http://www.cryptoex.com

------=_rE+2ToM)u)Slt6Q9N1.N6lerMQeL3s3Ge?hOe4ym7uCUUmuF/Ihy2ac+g'JR
Content-Type: application/octet-stream; name="pub.asc"
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="pub.asc"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
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=

------=_rE+2ToM)u)Slt6Q9N1.N6lerMQeL3s3Ge?hOe4ym7uCUUmuF/Ihy2ac+g'JR--