RFCs, standards, pink bunnies and flower patterns was -- Re: GPG Outlook Plug-In and Signatures

Mica Mijatovic blueness at gmx.net
Mon Oct 16 16:59:36 CEST 2006


-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

    Was Sun, 15 Oct 2006, at 22:27:36 -0500,
    when Ryan wrote:

> On 10/14/06, Werner Koch <wk at gnupg.org> wrote:
>> Anyway, HTML mails are evil.

> But unfortunately they're here to stay. RFC 2557 is now listed as
> "standards track".

RFCs are not any "standards" nor they are by (their own) definition
supposed to be.

They are just collection of less or more recommended routines, and often
also nothing but the lists of (most usual/mass) _habits_.

In order to define a _real_ standards, quite another criterions are
needed, created after essential _sense_ of a given act/procedure.

In this sense HTML definitely does not satisfy elementary needs to be
included in a crypto scheme (due to the very HTML's technical
characteristics).

                                   *

Of course that it doesn't mean that HTML should be banished completely
from the 'lectronic mail world, but it has its essential limitations as
for the cryptographic routines.

Once the grannies, moms, sisters, some presidents of some countries and
other particoloured fancy mail lovers are concerned with a possibly
needed encrypted/signed e-mail, and once they get wish to put their
letters in such a 'lectronic envelope they will grasp themselves why
this difference is important.

Until them let them play with their pink bunnies and flower patterns.

- --
Mica
~~~ For personal mail please use my address as it is *exactly* given
    in my "From" field, otherwise it will not reach me. ~~~
GPG keys/docs/software at: http://blueness.port5.com/pgpkeys/
                           http://tronogi.tripod.com/pgp/pgpkeys/
There are hackers and hack-uppers. (Hammer Von Troll)
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.6-svn-4217 <>o<> tiger192 i686 (MSYS/MinGW32)

iQEVAwUBRTOeV7SpHvHEUtv8AQiZngf+NyRqIiIi5olZHBCfcryABwes/czdyw8k
jJgEnEkIJaISejpTZ0sdFpeDKAsyo14xQIlgRtMo/sVxdN4TZ/5Fj0JnYstUff/A
ElqWkd673sVVW/2uvgx5MiD4p5KVNZZAU7Oz3c+GsJV7mH5YlTn/d0QpxE6I8efK
1Irc0y3vw0A8zn9/7IQKl3g0wNEd1+Ia4NST6lRyXe6XCMzaFVxiyeOjamdDWXCV
3ltFtQpyJU6rlqImK2TzYePuP3zOYq+ZorYRf46db0NPyMtxoT5IBy9teg3IOwp8
pP6zG0JvQTbMFevmoksJ1s7fvWc2s2mrWVwGKFS/IMSVFT2aFqLe4Q==
=uYMX
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----




More information about the Gnupg-users mailing list