Cannot find secret key error

Corrin Lakeland lakeland@cs.otago.ac.nz
Mon Sep 17 03:58:01 2001


--------------Boundary-00=_KOASBXKY2CF3XLB1Y520
Content-Type: text/plain;
  charset="us-ascii"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 8bit

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Hi all,

I'm trying to debug a strange problem, and I'm now stuck.

A friend of mine unsuccessfully attempted to send me an encrypted message.  
We both use gpg fairly regularly -- me hourly, him weekly, though this is the 
first encrypted message he has sent me.  He is using evolution 0.13 which 
sent the encrypted data as an attachment, I am slightly suspicious that 
evolution corrupted the data somehow, perhaps by changing the header. I use 
KMail which doesn't notice the attachment is GPG data but does let me save 
the attachment to a file.

I've attached everything that I thought might be useful: The message, My 
public key, his public key, a dump from the PGP data analyser, and the output 
from running gpg.

Does anybody have any idea what we've done wrong? My best guess is him using 
a nested key is confusing my gpg, or failing that something has broken 
encrypt only keys.

Oh, we don't don't have any need to encrypt our correspondence, but this is 
really starting to irritate me :-)

TIA,

Corrin
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.0.6 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: For info see http://www.gnupg.org

iD8DBQE7pVgXi5A0ZsG8x8cRAjN9AKCbsDRzQVQi7oTWYS6LT3vmHnvUcgCfXoe/
kIFu0hwZ+fvIeOisXz9A8w8=
=5SfV
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

--------------Boundary-00=_KOASBXKY2CF3XLB1Y520
Content-Type: application/pgp-keys;
  name="public_key.asc"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Description: Ben's public key
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="public_key.asc"
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--------------Boundary-00=_KOASBXKY2CF3XLB1Y520
Content-Type: application/pgp-keys;
  name="public_key.asc"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Description: My public key
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="public_key.asc"
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==

--------------Boundary-00=_KOASBXKY2CF3XLB1Y520
Content-Type: text/plain;
  charset="us-ascii";
  name="ben"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Description: Encrypted message
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="ben"
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=

--------------Boundary-00=_KOASBXKY2CF3XLB1Y520
Content-Type: text/x-c++;
  charset="us-ascii";
  name="decrypt"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Description: Output of gpg -d -v -v
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="decrypt"
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==

--------------Boundary-00=_KOASBXKY2CF3XLB1Y520
Content-Type: text/plain;
  charset="us-ascii";
  name="dump"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64
Content-Description: Output from data analyser
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="dump"
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--------------Boundary-00=_KOASBXKY2CF3XLB1Y520
Content-Type: message/rfc822;
  name="spool"
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Content-Description: Message in my mail spool
Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="spool"


>From ben.handley@softhome.net Sun Sep 16 10:55:25 2001
Return-Path: <ben.handley@softhome.net> Received: from atlas.otago.ac.nz (atlas.otago.ac.nz [139.80.32.250]) by freki.otago.ac.nz (8.11.2/8.11.2) with ESMTP id f8FMtPG18277 for <lakeland@freki.otago.ac.nz>; Sun, 16 Sep 2001 10:55:25 +1200 Received: from mail.acm.org (mail.acm.org [199.222.69.4]) by atlas.otago.ac.nz (8.9.3/8.9.3) with ESMTP id KAA312711 for <lakeland@cs.otago.ac.nz>; Sun, 16 Sep 2001 10:55:23 +1200 (NZST) Received: from deborah.paradise.net.nz (deborah.paradise.net.nz [203.96.152.32]) by mail.acm.org (8.9.3/8.9.3) with ESMTP id SAA91998 for <lakeland@acm.org>; Sat, 15 Sep 2001 18:54:23 -0400 Received: from erdos.house (203-79-67-238.tnt10.paradise.net.nz [203.79.67.238]) by deborah.paradise.net.nz (Postfix) with ESMTP id 99E461F9CB9 for <lakeland@acm.org>; Sun, 16 Sep 2001 10:54:23 +1200 (NZST) Received: from ben by erdos.house with local (Exim 3.31 #1 (Debian)) id 15iOK5-0000GC-00 for <lakeland@acm.org>; Sun, 16 Sep 2001 10:54:05 +1200 Subject: Re: Sorting a random list From: ben handley <ben.handley@softhome.net> To: Corrin Lakeland <lakeland@acm.org> Content-Type: multipart/encrypted; protocol="application/pgp-encrypted"; boundary="=-+1pCc6+Js7getYSjndDW" X-Mailer: Evolution/0.13 (Preview Release) Date: 16 Sep 2001 10:54:05 +1200 Message-Id: <1000594445.775.5.camel@erdos.house> Mime-Version: 1.0 Sender: ben <ben.handley@softhome.net> Status: RO X-Status: X-Keywords: X-UID: 391 --=-+1pCc6+Js7getYSjndDW Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Content-Type: application/pgp-encrypted Version: 1 --=-+1pCc6+Js7getYSjndDW Content-Type: application/octet-stream Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit -----BEGIN PGP MESSAGE----- Version: GnuPG v1.0.6 (GNU/Linux) Comment: For info see http://www.gnupg.org hQENA26hA0eahD9SEAP1EG0+57/JWjyLgjC1JjEm5FhA26pFouPk+P0ckU8o7Y0w EvJ77hQ/AaWcjH1liQXmNL7oUjMzKmP3s3vb0msdnirjGgqYP3pKxKXpXI8ssjDb U/VaowwMWdDeYa3k1tjqLSJaMv3OO4ycDG3F2pWK1MEA2gL3PLQQxCZhupyjhwP9 HHmW/2UeXzqwi7y2Z0gMir2BprjFARyEL5Yi0p0BsKLYX1umand/javhQPB/Xqtz KY0JPimz9ClhaF6SCFGsk1gOVL5l1dMHXyxa5WgqajZ90Fx6oPBNNDSktbxSstbY IBl5JcX/wvbTezirWmVYoe7itc6gsVwMo05l0FFlGCTS6gHi8bOkSOMnQ44EUjX8 VqDsefBlynK3hBUBCO323BtLLeHcqpCDP/xelcalH2f5+jm6UbXFHKMM+kfvyPye 4ECOMTISO9QsJ6yX0byhtJIuSh4aqUFi/bR1FxvnkQzpG31AWM1jYl67xJS5cyd9 j2E8RKHU59l0gRHu2CR0T1leV7+lFmxwq3I+2CqmfQAbv/8X8RPRSV8PQuPknj7A ipLAFVsTkFYL1hVJ+PSf/eRpSdakHSpGJ+kZkXkgLqm6P47B+w486wzJHJNqKwRi Bshtg/3MrDjQwN4A0GgXFIRYcw/Ij4DinPpzpK7RXelE5MYGaOsW+ufWAckZ5PbP J8r2pwXjOz50mk+H2EACLKo/pSRiDmV4my1Ohla9cfTxNXnnFRIaHEO+UDNMj+0M 2WEzayaJ8Fv+7bJHMxF9YLct5+CbgpoLojqB0qz0aQIZ2xo4rBiaOoAckW6wyAuj CD+51z/2kqGn63xVX4/seTwb86ohePHZOugusfIIa9igeNwa3AdMYuQZm4TGWF2T NOz0DrI7sQhjyE6kQSoKQmUXUh7jcObrvnWAczVkyCRzoqiC/dEZZXIP+5Wmwwyf veUtC5LSbao7U2li66ERsl7ZMJlq2I/UVuLH2Gt1K0CzJbfWKqZJirZxuQ9UBGRX 8v1MqFcNKQ5XneMKuvFtouXrF2YZA3I0+fBrOa5KJ8eGzLpxiLHfSjMcBH+RjDPt vrepZw0kb/3vfNWbg2o7jLjYmM00N1yTNCAitg1ibtIRvg2OOEeoAxy5p8sjUpyT CXmfVwfhHvDq/rzRqolgIdUHV11jeiUMKjb59Dg7fqAGH+XCOx44QOStmfHWTX1w +Y3HmbaAz2OXnnF1T13LRog53LJn4mm8zS9/hOsTs0T4fg1E+vedzpPRyFFVvhgh pbsjk+GNZM9Bhgr5MHLk6aqVnY2VIZ1YJJZ2NXge3JQYbHaVC6h04mE2R7buYX16 iQd11aUJ9NiTCLglcs0GrflV4NLQAu8deQPW8u+uwRLPHtgnZbhPQPQV8R7AozFM wvM1WtI2amcyhcK6veq0BiTVL/Y06S4QVDJH7Q9dEO5tlDumaZqHHsFxl+50MYsG rglSE/T5Ry7n4u0JOwFfu4sYWhmq0rS0Ut6isx5+FfLfAx02/pfGixoiUKxFUel5 AP2p9Rvwgt6dQkmLZg0ccNKjlxBMiu79JyD3oXmG1l3H+p+CYpO2Wx9maudI8nf1 nZgzlpuzTy1RxxHzMxRQEVaPvg63SkcsNIn7sa2s2F76aH2REeLhs8lU2Ko3SQR+ Xh/FNjWnfeoFfJPSwy9K2bujX5hgAQUn+WOKLA2eRpVaDuOWYnP3HRad1eONO4fb FTDAg3JAJQxru0nSVGrY9hasTXcbFvarZUuFPCmuEe9bIjNjl/whhQ1D1iVenGMK zCcWLJJCFc/Hbu6eVTr5/PJ06heBwZE96qc5jWYJwJ7n6dF/7eio8gYlkJZXYnGb klS1wBeI25NZIVpcb2o5TTKe5lBRMCqoxsuHxaKeW0zv09ns2UAyoTLbBam5LMyT f5MKSjeZzIMjTIFZpHIVf3JHROzaIgjiaB3+q+g87sjDLCCuLCEfDki+YY98F3w7 jxfco5p2dBc5Xud1rGzY4AHVVSkkn8gsyycJLWQc8NfP6HB1Bvc1jtxgW29UsyLx 4U7eBpjG/3d7s0XnnIep7UshBYZBzDA68iJjtQ+0aTn8hZuwsY8QL8wwCyLtsu5t 5ypB72YMfIYB4TO6DuwSM8nhU/m9TmQBeMXxjHuqR6PrXSb9raaF =/fL3 -----END PGP MESSAGE----- --=-+1pCc6+Js7getYSjndDW-- --------------Boundary-00=_KOASBXKY2CF3XLB1Y520--