Malformed Revokation Certificate?

[Jay Litwyn]

I submitted this revokation certificate to a couple of servers and
they said it was malformed,
and I had trouble guessing how to generate anything different. So, I
imported the revokation certificate, exported the whole key, and
submitted that. It worked.

Thanks to the availability of PGP 2.6.3i, I am now the proud user of
a public key that has my name and my email addresses on different
packets, and for which the encryption key and the signing key are
identical. Thanks to the availability of PGP 10.x, a photo is on my
public key. GPG won't put photos on PGP 2.x keys. It can. No matter
what the relevant Request For Comments (RFC) says, it can. It makes
the key unimportable by PGP 2.6.3i, and the key servers have it.

I have a hybrid key.

The key servers can also import public keys designed for SSL and
S/MIME. PGP 10 will export them. GPG won't import them, though --
something about invalid user ids. It says the same thing about the
public key for a time stamper (invalid user id). Maybe GPG should be
more tolerant.

Sigh. The public key I want to use is already on my GnuPG public and
private key rings. When the signature on this e-mail failed, I went
in to the GUI key management, and found that I am using a different
version on the CLI. We are _losing_ features, here. Maybe it'll
import into version 2.x if I delete the photo.

gpg (GnuPG) 1.2.2
Copyright (C) 2003 Free Software Foundation, Inc.

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: GnuPG v1.2.2 (MingW32)
Comment: http://ecn.ab.ca/~brewhaha/gpg/Keyprint_Biometric.mp3.pgp
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=Bd6h
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----

iOkEIAECAFQFAlAhAVlNHQJJIGZvdW5kIGEgcGFzc3dvcmQgc3RlYWxlciBhbmQg
YSByZW1vdGUgY29kZSBleGVjdXRpb24gdG9vbCBvbiBteSBjb21wdXRlci4ACgkQ
HjtqnNd0gPaEVgP3eXtePlejx+qc7/HzAoEoHTbw1o9nZiI6VMsgFMF3OPzx21bI
4WENrd6luDXV2bxSv0rqHZIpPm8RecRx13rPVkXyiI1Pt8//siPQSlcnesdgirsp
BPHNzOhlcrBOOak6pQ4NNj0VtDoz9O4sheeJqbAdndeHS7H8HIB22ri7CQ==
=EJrI
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----